Releases & Statements
In the Media
Newsletter
Photo Gallery
Contact

 
 

Releases & Statements

 

Gotbaum: Court’s Decision on MTA Lawsuit a Loss for all New Yorkers

“Subway and bus riders got sacked,” said Public Advocate Betsy Gotbaum after hearing about the court ruling. “Not only are riders going to wind up paying for the sweetheart deal between the MTA and the Jets, this decision also sets a bad precedent, allowing government agencies to predetermine the outcome of bids.”

“New York City subway and bus riders deserve to have a fare that’s fair and transportation that gets you where you’re going on time. That’s what this lawsuit aimed to do: prevent the MTA from squandering precious resources at a time when its balance sheet is full of red ink and the subways are full of problems.

Betsy Gotbaum filed suit against the Metropolitan Transit Authority (MTA) over its handling of the bidding process for the Hudson Rail Yards. Gotbaum sought to stop the MTA from selling the right to build over the rail yards to the Jets on the grounds that the process was unfair and the deal was not in the best interests of New Yorkers.

“The MTA failed to fulfill its legal responsibility to transit riders and New York City residents,” said Gotbaum on the day she filed the suit. “The Board of Directors apparently doesn’t get it: subway service is a disaster. It’s time to start worrying about the deteriorating state of our public transportation system.”

Gotbaum’s suit, which was filed in Supreme Court, asserted that, by accepting the Jets’ bid, the MTA was in breach of its fiduciary duty to make the deal “most beneficial” to the public and to ensure a process “that fosters fair and open competition, is conducted under the highest ethical standards, and enjoys the complete confidence of the public.” The suit detailed a series of statements and actions on the part of the MTA that suggested the process was manipulated to favor the Jets.


 

Back to top

 

 

The Public Advocate's Office • 1 Centre Street, 15th Floor • New York, NY 10007 • General Inquiries: (212) 669-7200
Ombudsman Services: (212) 669-7250 • Fax: (212) 669-4091