Public Advocate Banner
Home About Press Policy Contact
About the Office
Betsy Gotbaum
Contact
News
Press Releases
Policy
Reports
Reports
Reports
Get Help
How We Can Help
Commission on School Governance
Public Advocate's Blog
 
 
 

Releases & Statements

 

Statement of Public Advocate Betsy Gotbaum on NYPD Subway Searches

“While I fully understand the need for heightened security in the wake of the 7/7 and 7/21 attacks on London’s mass transit system, it is of the utmost importance that NYPD officers receive strict instructions not to single out individuals for search on the basis of race, ethnicity, or religious garb. Officers who disobey this order should be severely disciplined.

“To help ensure that those being searched aren't being racially profiled, the NYPD must keep strict records on the ethnicity and race of everyone searched. So-called random searches are unnerving: if they are not conducted on a strictly random basis, they will go against the basic premise of our Bill of Right. Furthermore, if New Yorkers do not trust police officers to respect their civil liberties, the NYPD’s ability to keep the public safe will be compromised.

“Early reports of reaction to the new policy suggest that most commuters are willing to accept the inconvenience of random searches if they are necessary to improve transit security. I have complete faith in Police Commissioner Kelly’s ability to conduct searches that helps ensure our safety while not violating civil rights; however, some New Yorkers, are uneasy about the possibility of abuse. The NYPD can answer these concerns by guaranteeing that officers confine their searches to materials relevant to terrorist activity and treat apprehensive commuters with civility."

 

 

Back to top